Optional cookies require your permission.Privacy & cookies
In this essay11 sections
  1. A second nationality creates an option, not an obligation.
  2. Separate an application from an acquired nationality.
  3. A fictional household needs three different answers.
  4. Model the tax position before choosing a date.
  5. Bitcoin creates a valuation problem and a cash problem.
  6. Do not let two authorities silently determine each other’s deadline.
  7. The record needs to survive the transition.
  8. Plan the obligations that remain afterward.
  9. Include the next generation in the financial review.
  10. Assign responsibility and preserve the choice to stop.
  11. The Bitcoin Lawyer take

A second nationality creates an option, not an obligation.

El Salvador citizenship may provide an alternative nationality to assess before a US citizen considers renunciation. The planning principle is to establish a dependable alternative before surrendering a major existing right, without confusing prudent preparation with a universal legal prerequisite. But obtaining another nationality does not commit someone to an exit. Keeping both, where the relevant laws allow it, may remain the best outcome.

It is also important to state the US rule accurately. Another nationality is not an absolute legal prerequisite to renunciation. The State Department warns that renunciation can leave a person stateless and create serious difficulties with travel, work, and ordinary life. That warning supports careful sequencing; it does not justify inventing a prohibition that the government does not impose.

A serious plan starts with the life after the proposed change. Where can the person live, work, receive care and maintain a family home? Which rights are already secure, and which still depend on an application? A passport photograph is a poor substitute for those answers. The decision should remain reversible until the necessary facts are established.

Separate an application from an acquired nationality.

An El Salvador program submission, an accepted contribution, and an approved naturalization are different events. The government’s Freedom Passport portal describes the naturalization process following the payment stages and passport issuance after authorization. A payment receipt therefore cannot be treated as proof that the applicant is already Salvadoran.

The portal describes a USD 1 million contribution paid in Bitcoin or USDT and family inclusion for a spouse and children under eighteen. Do not extend that household description to adult children, parents, or grandparents because an older commercial article did so. Confirm each person’s eligibility and the applicable charges through the actual process.

Before tying an exit decision to this route, obtain the nationality instrument, establish its effective date, and resolve the practical identity documents needed afterward. Check the naturalized person’s retention position as well. The alternative should remain usable through an ordinary change of residence or a family emergency, not merely on the day the certificate arrives.

A fictional household needs three different answers.

Consider Owen, a fictional US citizen with a long-held Bitcoin position, a spouse who has another nationality, and a nineteen-year-old daughter studying in the United States. Owen likes El Salvador’s Bitcoin culture and can afford a substantial contribution. He initially describes the project as moving the whole family through one passport application.

That description hides separate problems. His daughter is outside the portal’s stated under-eighteen child category. His spouse’s existing rights may already solve some residence needs. Owen’s US nationality decision is personal and does not change either relative’s status. The family must establish individual routes before discussing a common move.

The daughter also changes the access question. Owen may want to visit her for graduations, illness, or an extended period of support. After nationality loss, his ability to enter the United States would depend on the rules applicable to a foreign national. A second passport should not be described as preserving the former citizen’s unconditional right to return.

He therefore tests two plans: retain US citizenship while adding another nationality, or consider expatriation after the family’s rights and obligations have been reviewed. The first plan is not a failed version of the second. It may deliver the continuity he actually wanted without creating an access problem he had not priced.

Model the tax position before choosing a date.

The US expatriation analysis includes three covered-expatriate tests. The fixed net-worth threshold is USD 2 million or more. The other tests concern average annual net income tax liability over the preceding five years and certification of compliance with federal tax obligations for those years. A person does not escape the certification test merely by having a modest balance sheet.

For 2026, Revenue Procedure 2025-32 sets the income-tax-liability threshold at more than USD 211,000 and the mark-to-market gain reduction at USD 910,000. These are different figures serving different purposes. The gain reduction is not an exclusion from the net-worth test, and it is not a separate allowance for every wallet.

The narrow exceptions for certain dual citizens at birth and certain minors have their own conditions. A nationality acquired later through an investment program does not turn someone into a dual citizen at birth. Nor do these exceptions remove the need for the required compliance certification.

Have the responsible US tax professional document the applicable tests, assumptions, and unresolved items before an appointment date starts driving the analysis. A calendar deadline should follow a completed assessment. It should not force the professional to reconstruct years of missing records after a consequential act.

Bitcoin creates a valuation problem and a cash problem.

Owen’s fictional balance sheet contains Bitcoin worth USD 2.4 million with documented aggregate basis of USD 400,000. The difference is USD 2 million. That simple subtraction is useful for seeing the scale of an unrealized gain, but it is not his exit-tax calculation. Other assets, debts, ownership, valuation dates, and special categories still need review.

The ordinary mark-to-market framework concerns a deemed disposal immediately before expatriation. Certain deferred compensation, specified tax-deferred accounts, and nongrantor trust interests receive separate treatment. They cannot all be placed in one spreadsheet column and described as sheltered from the exit analysis.

Owen must also fund the citizenship contribution and any tax payment. If he disposes of appreciated Bitcoin to make the contribution while still a US taxpayer, that transaction needs its own tax analysis. It is not safe to model the contribution as reducing his stack without considering the disposal used to fund it.

His advisor should therefore compare complete sequences using defensible valuations and liquidity assumptions. A price movement can change the resources available for the contribution and the tax exposure. A plan that works only at one attractive market quote is too fragile for a process with uncertain administrative timing.

Do not let two authorities silently determine each other’s deadline.

Owen’s destination application could complete before his tax records are ready, or the tax assessment could be complete while nationality approval remains outstanding. Neither sequence authorizes him to treat the unfinished part as done. He needs separate evidence for each decision and a practical way to keep the project paused without losing track of document validity.

For example, a consular appointment offered earlier than expected can feel like an opportunity that must be taken. If Owen still lacks the alternative nationality instrument, the convenient appointment does not repair that gap. Conversely, receipt of the Salvadoran documents does not establish that a particular US expatriation date is financially or procedurally suitable.

His household should also agree what happens if the project stops after the second nationality is acquired. Maintaining that status, renewing documents, and preserving the records remain useful tasks. They should have owners and a budget even if the citizenship renunciation never happens. An alternative becomes dependable through those ordinary arrangements, not through the momentum of the original application.

The record needs to survive the transition.

An exit plan for a long-term holder should preserve acquisition records, wallet histories, valuations, and ownership evidence before accounts are closed or identities are updated. A later reviewer may need to understand the position as it stood on a particular date. Current wallet control does not explain every historical acquisition or establish every tax basis.

For Owen, an exchange account opened years earlier may contain the only accessible transaction export. He should obtain the relevant records through ordinary authorized access while available, then reconcile them with his own history. Screenshots of a current balance cannot reconstruct the original purchases, transfers, and fees.

The tax professional and the nationality professional also need consistent facts. Names, dates, family relationships, and source-of-funds explanations should not diverge because different advisors received different versions. Coordination means sharing appropriate evidence securely, with the client’s authority. It does not mean giving every participant wallet secrets or unrestricted access to personal files.

Plan the obligations that remain afterward.

Loss of US nationality is not a statement that the IRS can never have another claim. Existing liabilities and required filings do not disappear. A former citizen may also face US tax on relevant US-source income or income connected with a US trade or business, depending on the facts and applicable rules.

The transition year deserves explicit work: the relevant tax date, return treatment, information reporting, and any continuing obligations. Institutional account records must be updated truthfully using the evidence the institution requires. A foreign passport alone does not prove that US status has ended, and account documentation is not a substitute for personal filing obligations.

Owen should ask what happens to a US rental property, a business interest, and investment distributions he plans to retain. Each can create a continuing connection. The point is not that expatriation achieves nothing; it is that its effect must be measured against his actual assets rather than a claim that all future US taxation ends.

Include the next generation in the financial review.

Covered expatriates face a further issue when planning what they may later give or leave to others: certain later gifts or bequests to US citizens or residents can fall within section 2801. The recipient’s position matters, and the rules are not confined to a payment made immediately after expatriation. Form 708 now provides the reporting mechanism.

The IRS instructions use a USD 19,000 annual amount for 2026 and a forty per cent calculation on net covered gifts and bequests, subject to the applicable definitions, exceptions, and adjustments. This should not become a blanket assertion that every transfer to anyone living in America is taxed in exactly the same way.

Owen wants his daughter eventually to receive part of his Bitcoin. That intention belongs in the assessment before he acts. The advisor needs to examine the intended recipient, timing, transfer form, and records. Moving the coins to a different wallet or writing a new will does not itself answer whether the transfer falls within the regime.

Assign responsibility and preserve the choice to stop.

Bitcoin Lawyer can help assess the cross-border planning questions. Any retained work would require confirmed availability and a separate accepted engagement defining the in-house CPA work and separately engaged local professionals where needed. The scope should identify who performs the US tax assessment, who handles nationality advice and procedure, and who follows the destination documents. The firm’s advisory role is not a claim of legal admission.

Before proceeding, Owen needs a written understanding of the outstanding questions and the events that would pause the plan. An incomplete family route, unresolved tax records, changed financial capacity, or an unexpected nationality condition can justify delay. Money already spent on advice is not a reason to make a worse irreversible decision.

The second nationality can still be valuable if Owen decides to remain American. Evaluate it on its own cost, rights, maintenance, and family fit. That keeps the decision centered on Owen’s actual needs, without treating citizenship acquisition and renunciation as one inevitable purchase or a sequence he must complete.

The whole picture

The Bitcoin Lawyer take

Confirm the second nationality and its practical rights before evaluating nationality loss. Retaining both citizenships can remain a valid outcome when the household has examined the alternatives.

Complete the family, tax, liquidity, and future-access analysis before surrendering an existing right. The strongest outcome may be a properly prepared exit, or it may be retaining both nationalities. The work should make that choice clearer, not predetermine it.

Cite this essay

Adam Juchniewicz, CEO, Bitcoin Lawyer. “Would a second nationality change a US citizen’s decision to renounce?” https://www.bitcoinlawyer.com/journal/el-salvador-citizenship-before-a-us-exit